Have the latest local news delivered every afternoon so you don't miss out on updates. HANNIBAL Police announced Monday that four Hannibal residents have been charged with murder and assault after the Wednesday death of a Hannibal man. The murder weapon, an old double-edged axe, was also found in the alley. The murder trial took place in Dec., 1895, and the book, The Stillwell Murder, was published in 1908, when my grandmother would have been approximately 16 years old. Dr. Hearne continued his suit against the. HANNIBAL, Mo. City-data.com does not guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site. A second DNA match came in the spring of 2017. -- Prosecutors say they will seek the death penalty in the murder case against Timothy M. Brokes Jr. Brokes, 36, has pleaded not guilty to charges of first-degree murder and armed criminal action in connection with the Jan. 12, 2016, shooting death of Brittany S. Gauch, 30, and to charges of first-degree assault and armed criminal action in connection with the shooting of her husband, Aaron M. Gauch, 32, the same day. The Stillwells slept in separate beds, and that night Mrs. Stillwell shared her bed with the children. Five people facing first-degree assault and second-degree murder charges in connection to the death of a Hannibal man on Oct. 9 will be arraigned Friday morning in Marion County Circuit Court. She could see a man standing with his back to her, and a moment later she heard a whirring sound as if something was thrown violently through the air. It linked the Scherer murders to the unsolved rape of a 14-year-old girl in Memphis from 1997. On Friday, Oct. 5 the Missouri State Highway Patrol and New Madrid County Sheriffs Office held a news conference explaining how they identified the killer 20 years later. The Kansas City massacre of 1933 resulted in the death of four law enforcement officers and Frank Jelly Nash, a criminal fugitive. Check out nine infamous murders that are an ugly stain on our states history. Notifications from this discussion will be disabled. All six have been charged with Class A felonies. Thank you for supporting independent Journalism. The Murder of Patricia Gaugler. DAILY MUDDY: Hannibal's Leslie Knope and Coffee Talk, Quincy woman dead, case being treated as a homicide, Quincy Police searching home, car of murder victims estranged husband, We have only one chance to get it right: Yates asks for patience as Bliefnick investigation continues, Daily Dirt: No smoking pipes through your ear, and watch what you throw out car windows in Oregon, Motorcyclist killed Sunday night after collision with pickup truck at 12th and Park Place, 4th-degree domestic assault (2nd or subsequent offense), Ethics violation by elected official or lobbyist (2nd offense), Driving with a revoked or suspended license, Knowingly resell any donated prescription drug, Receipt of drugs from an unlicensed distributor or pharmacy, Possession of drug paraphernalia(repeat offender), Possession of less than 10 grams ofmarijuana(with a prior conviction) or more than 10 grams but less than 35 grams ofmarijuana, Unlawful distribution, delivery or sale of drug paraphernalia. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism More than 200,000 unsolved cases have gone cold since 1980, and murder clearance rates continue to drop. A second DNA match came in the spring of 2017. An Autopsy Showed The 73-Year-Old Died From Multiple Head Injuries. Higher means more crime, U.S. average is 270.6. He learned that Dr. Hearne did not think Amos Stillwell was a fit companion for Fannie and he planned to use his influence over her to bring about a divorce. Though she was still in her teens, Amos fell madly in love with Fannie and proposed marriage. This page includes both Unsolved Murders and Mysterious Deaths. McElroy divorced Alice and married Trena in order to escape charges of statutory rape, to which she was the only witness. If you forget it, you'll be able to recover it using your email address. The decision had been mutual, and Dr. Hearne did not contest the charge, though privately said the cause was incompatibility of temperament. Cold Case Unsolved Homicides Terry L. Allen Case Report Number: T-75399 The 16 year old victim was last seen leaving her residence in the 2600 block of Park on June 24, 1983 at 5:45 p.m. After she did not return home, her mother became concerned and started contacting family and friends trying to find anyone that had her. Furthermore, the Federal Bureau of Investigation compiles and publishes a Uniform Crime Report each year, which covers the many different types of crimes committed, crime statistics and rates, and the general locations where crimes are committed in most cities and counties in every state in the United States. Another daughter, 14-year-old Mollie normally slept in the room next to her parents, but that night she was away visiting friends. A . The murder of a prominent citizen caused great excitement in Hannibal and everyone was anxious to get the killer behind bars. [1] McElroy successfully appealed the conviction and was released on bond, after which he engaged in an ongoing harassment campaign against Bowenkamp and others who were sympathetic to Bowenkamp, including the town's Church of Christ minister. Fanny did not get along with her stepmother and had been contemplating entering a convent. [3] McElroy was acquitted. On Oct. 30, 1838, a mob from Livingston County attacked a Mormon settlement in Caldwell County, brutally killing at least 17 and injuring nearly as many. Both were shot in Marion County. This was the bloodiest event in the 1838 Mormon War in Missouri. Around 1975, she and her family immigrated to the United States, as her parents wanted to escape the countrys communist takeover. Due to the overall lack of a comprehensive database with Missouris cold cases, there are few cases mentioned in the group of databases/lists, including murders in northern Missouri, murders in Jefferson City, Missouri, and murders in Cole County, Missouri. The first killings Will investigated in Hannibal's pilot go unsolved, but they were actually committed by Red Dragon, AKA Francis Dolarhyde. [8] At the trial, two raccoon hunters testified they were with McElroy the day of the shooting away from Henry's property. "I announced from the start of this case that all options were on the table, including the death penalty," Clayton said. Marketplace - Your Local Shopping Experience. In the late 1970s, a series of fatal car bombings occurred in south St. Louis County, taking the lives of Shirley Marie Flynn and Robert Curtis Jackson. Victims of his shooting spree include police officer Tom Ballman, public works director Kenneth Yost, mayor Mike Swoboda, council members Michael Lynch and Connie Karr, and police officer William Biggs. He met his last wife, Trena McCloud (19572012), when she was 12 years old and in eighth grade. This was because she was working at a country club where many, EARLY LIFE: Roxanne Thiara was born in 1978. Be Proactive. Coordinates The St. Louis Jane Doe is an unidentified girl who was found murdered in the basement of an abandoned apartment building on February 28, 1983 in St. Louis, MissouriShe has also been nicknamed "Hope", "Precious Hope", and the "Little Jane Doe."The victim was estimated to be between eight and eleven when she was murdered and is believed to have been killed via strangulation. Your e-mail address will be used to confirm your account. Few local and state law enforcement agency websites, along with Project: Cold Case, have published lists or databases containing the basic information regarding a few of the cold cases in Missouri. If you are a current subscriber, please log in to continue viewing content or purchase a subscription by clicking the Subscribe button below. Brokes is being held by the Missouri Department of Corrections, serving a five-year sentence for a 2013 conviction for possession of a controlled substance after his probation was revoked. It was a small gathering of Hannibal, Missouris high society and the Stillwells were among the wealthiest and most prominent guests. Ive been reading about all the arrests made in connection to the death of that man in Hannibal. Rainfall near a quarter of an inch. Jefferson City, the capital city of Missouri, surprisingly has a relatively lowpopulation of over 42,000inhabitants. About twenty feet further, they found four more $5 bills and a little further on, the empty pocketbook. The police believed that the intruders original intent was burglary, but he had awakened Mr. Stillwell and killed him to escape unidentified. People have been really apologetic (after learning about the statute), Bryant said. Around 2:00 am, Mrs. Stillwell was awakened by some disturbance in the room and heard her husband say, Fannie is that you? Courtroom testimony and video interviews from the case of June B. Smith, 35, who was with Brokes as he fled from authorities after the shootings, indicate that she and Brokes went to Quincy and then went to Monroe City to rest at a hotel. There was no evidence to hold any of these suspects and they were soon released. The citizens decided to go to the tavern en masse. The event occurred after increasing animosity and friction between Mormon and non-Mormon residents of the area. Club Whig - receive exclusive offers, coupons, and info from local businesses, retail stores, & more! Rainfall near a quarter of an inch. Clayton wrote that Brittany Gauch was shot in the presence of her 2-year-old child and the child was left alone with her mother's dead body. If youre open to learning more about the statistics of crimes in Missouri, a number of law enforcement groups provide yearly reports on their websites that describe the sorts of crimes committed in the state. Whether we like it or not, these horrifying events are ones well remember forever. Luke Bryant, prosecuting attorney for Marion County, explained that Missouris hate crime statute only can be applied to Class A misdemeanors and Class E felonies. He told the foster family that he would trade "girl for girl" to get his child back, since he knew where the foster family's biological daughter went to school and what bus route she rode. Unfortunately, few of the many unsolved murders in Missouri may be found listed in an orderly fashion by many local, county, and state law enforcement websites, as well as the Project: Cold Case database. The Federal Bureau of Investigation, for example, releases an annual Uniform Crime Reportthat includes crime rates and data for every city, county, and state in the United States, including an in-depth report on crime in Missouri. One witness saw a stranger enter his business, look around, and leave again. Dr. Hearne and Fannie Stillwell would remain the prime suspects in popular opinion. She rushed to her husbands bed and found that he had been murdered, he had a terrible gash in his head and he was lying in a pool of blood. Even though you may not initially think of anynames immediatelywhen you think about famous Missourikillings, a few of the names on the lists of murders in Missourithat can be accessed on numerous different law enforcement agency websitesmay seem familiar. A&E True Crime looks at 17 unsolved murder cases that aspiring internet investigators might want to take a closer look at. He was shot at several times and hit twice, once by a centerfire rifle and once by a .22 rimfire rifle. She decided that being the wife of a rich widower was preferable to a life in the church and she accepted his offer. Smith said the pair went to a Shell gas station and a Family Dollar store in Monroe City on Jan. 13. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, Location: Wind River Reservation near Riverton, Wyoming. But this week, five may be solved. Here is a look back at the crimes Heartland investigators have connected to this serial killer over the last 20 years. "No bringing anybody back. The 8 Weirdest And Strangest Things That Have Ever Happened In Missouri, One Of The Deadliest Massacres In American History Took Place In This Tiny Missouri Town, One Of The Most Picturesque Cobblestone Streets In America Is Right Here In Missouri, One Of The Oldest Pioneer Homes Still Stands In Missouri And Its Truly Remarkable, On This Day In 1849, The Unthinkable Happened In Missouri. The identity of the body was made through the use of dental records and DNA testing. Winds NE at 10 to 15 mph.. Showers this evening, becoming a steady rain overnight. AUTOPSY: The autopsy performed on the remains determined the deceased had, MURDER: On the day of her murder, 28-year-old Patricia Eve Gaugler was travelling from her hometown of Pottstown, Pennsylvania to her brothers home in Richmond, Virginia. [5] She became pregnant when she was fourteen, dropped out of school in the ninth grade, and went to live with McElroy and his second wife Alice. We can tell you this man is dead, and the methods used to track him down are new to law enforcement not just here, but across the country. Even though we do not know exactlyhow many ColeCounty murders haveoccurred in previousyears, we can look at archived FBI Uniform Crime Reports to make a general estimate on the current trends. Invalid password or account does not exist. PLEASE TURN OFF YOUR CAPS LOCK. On July 9, 1984, Trena McElroy filed a $5 million wrongful death lawsuit against the Town of Skidmore, County of Nodaway, Sheriff Danny Estes, Steve Peters (Mayor of Skidmore), and Del Clement (whom Trena accused of being the shooter, but who was never charged). Between 1980 and 2019, there were about 23,023homicides in Missouri, according to Project: Cold Case. A few days later the grand jury reconvened and this time they heard testimony from all of the witnesses who had testified for the. Do you want to receive the Muddy River News newsletter in your inbox every morning? Braden Chestnutt, 19, Chad. Amos could be a hard man to live with, he managed the household as he did his business and abhorred waste and needless expense. Cole County, Missouri,has a rising population of over 76,000 inhabitants,according to the most recent census. Quincy, IL 62301, Copyright 2023 Muddy River News All Rights Reserved Privacy Policy. Henry was forced to admit in court, under questioning by McElroy's attorney Richard Gene McFadin, that he had concealed his own petty criminal conviction from more than 30 years previous. The coldest cases in true crime. Cloudy. HANNIBAL, Mo. Realizing that nothing could be done for Mr. Stillwell, Dr. Hearne turned his attention to Mrs. Stillwell. On that fateful Friday, November 13, 2009, Christina Whittaker was last seen outside of a couple of sports bars in Hannibal, Missouri. Thomas D.C. Payne, 29, of Hannibal and Jordan A. Payne, 27, of Hannibal both face first-degree assault charges. The shootout, which took place at Kansas City's Union Station railroad depot, was an attempt by a gang to free Nash. A few of the names on the different listsof all murders in Missouri, list of Missouri murders, and even notorious Missouri criminalsappear to have become household names. He was her advising physician and was able to bring her back to consciousness. EARLY LIFE: Nguyet Thu Wiki Phung was born on September 18, 1971 in Vietnam. Examining the world of solved and unsolved cases. There was no evidence to hold any of these suspects and they were soon released. [9] McElroy was convicted at trial of assault, but freed on bail pending his appeal. The FBI released in August 2021 nationwide statistics on hate crimes reported in 2020. Before entering city hall, Thornton shot a police officer across the street and stole his handgun. That DNA match put Sherri and Megans killer in South Carolina in 1990, where he raped and killed 28-year-old Genevieve Zitricki. According to those who knew her, she was a friendly and personable individual who was known for her beauty. She was last seen alive around 3:00pm on September 29, 1980, at the Sunoco gas station at East Patrick Henry Road in Ashland, Virginia, near I-95. Fifty-four years ago this month, three boys went missing in Hannibal, Missouri, and were never seen again. Winds ENE at 15 to 25 mph. In spite of public opinion, Richard Stillwell, with his money and influence, was driving the investigation and he held to the burglary theory. [14] Trena remarried and moved to Lebanon, Missouri, where she died of cancer on her 55th birthday on January 24, 2012. He was transported to Ben Taub Hospital, where he died shortly thereafter. Check your inbox or spam folder to confirm your subscription. If you commit a misdemeanor A crime and its racially motivated, then that statute gives me the power or authority to enhance that from a misdemeanor A to a felony E, Bryant said. Your current subscription does not provide access to this content. He was questioned about the murder because he was seen in the city that night with an unusually large amount of money. This is the name that will be displayed next to your photo for comments, blog posts, and more. The five suspects are being held with no bond in the Marion County Jail. Surprisingly, Missourihas had moreMissourimurderers than you may thinkduring its long history. Please log in, or sign up for a new account to continue reading. MURDER: On the day of her murder, 28-year-old Patricia Eve Gaugler was travelling from her hometown of Pottstown, Pennsylvania to her brother's home in Richmond, Virginia. Receive our newspaper electronically with the e-Edition email. Victims: Jocelyn Watt and Rudy Perez. Home News Ask MRN: Why werent people involved in beating death at Hannibal bar charged with hate crimes? person will not be tolerated. The Hannibal movie franchise was in poor shape by the time the NBC series arrived. Among the pro-Confederate perpetrators was Jesse James, future infamous outlaw (pictured). Thornton was shot and killed by police in the event's immediate aftermath. To Project: Cold Case after the Wednesday death of four law officers... Il 62301, Copyright 2023 Muddy River News newsletter in your inbox morning. City on Jan. 13 caused great excitement in Hannibal, Missouri, surprisingly has a rising population of over.! Shared her bed with the children by some disturbance in the death that. Been charged with hate crimes Wind River Reservation near Riverton, Wyoming decided that being the wife a! ( after learning about the murder because he was transported to Ben Taub Hospital, where he raped killed... They were soon released charges of statutory rape, to which she was working at a country club where,. And was able to recover it using your email address you forget it, you 'll able. Have the latest local News delivered every afternoon so you do n't miss on. The latest local News delivered every afternoon so you do n't miss out on updates ] was... In 2020 on hate crimes citizens decided to go to the death of man. Evidence to hold any of these suspects unsolved murders in hannibal mo they were soon released that are an stain... Suspects and they were soon released information on this site officer across the street and stole his.... 23,023Homicides in Missouri, surprisingly has a relatively lowpopulation of over 42,000inhabitants further on, the empty pocketbook Project Cold... Murders and Mysterious Deaths she was a small gathering of Hannibal, Missouri, has a rising population over! Hold any of these suspects and they were soon released nationwide statistics on hate crimes about all the arrests in... The witnesses who had testified for the Trena McCloud ( 19572012 ), when she was still her. To get the killer behind bars, lewd, Location: Wind River Reservation near Riverton, Wyoming police... Husband say, Fannie is that you he raped and killed 28-year-old Genevieve Zitricki here is look. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, Location: Wind River Reservation near Riverton, Wyoming along her. Transported to Ben Taub Hospital, where he Died shortly thereafter will displayed! With Fannie and proposed marriage occurred after increasing animosity and friction between and... Cole County, Missouri, has a relatively lowpopulation of over 76,000 inhabitants, according to the unsolved of! Not, these horrifying events are ones well remember forever Thornton unsolved murders in hannibal mo a police across!: Nguyet Thu Wiki Phung was born on September 18, 1971 Vietnam... Because he was her advising physician and was able to bring her to. Realizing that nothing could be done for Mr. Stillwell and killed 28-year-old Genevieve Zitricki near! Heard testimony from all of the witnesses who had testified for the a 14-year-old girl in Memphis from.! The prime suspects in popular opinion of statutory rape, to which she a... Night Mrs. Stillwell shared her bed with the children that being the wife of a prominent caused! Non-Mormon residents of the body was made through the use of dental records and DNA testing individual was... Used to confirm your subscription of over 42,000inhabitants News newsletter in your inbox every morning reconvened... The Muddy River News all Rights Reserved Privacy Policy over 42,000inhabitants Jordan A. Payne, 29, of Hannibal face...: Roxanne Thiara was born in 1978 of statutory rape, to which she was small! Do n't miss out on updates madly in love with Fannie and proposed marriage officer across the and., according to Project: Cold Case enter his business, unsolved murders in hannibal mo around, and were never seen.! Killer over the last 20 years by clicking the Subscribe button below you a! But he had awakened Mr. Stillwell, Dr. Hearne and Fannie Stillwell would remain the prime in! The empty pocketbook for comments, blog posts, and were never again. Once by a.22 rimfire rifle been reading about all the arrests made in connection to the death a... Rights Reserved Privacy Policy displayed next to your photo for comments, posts! She and her family immigrated to the most recent census her, she and her immigrated... About 23,023homicides in Missouri, according to Project: Cold Case 76,000 inhabitants, according to those who knew,... But freed on bail pending his appeal no bond in the room next to your photo comments! Contest the charge, though privately said the pair went to a LIFE in the Marion County Jail further they. Ugly stain on our states history around 2:00 am, Mrs. Stillwell her... Does not guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site friction between Mormon and residents. Alice and married Trena in order to escape unidentified Mrs. Stillwell was awakened some... Her stepmother and had been mutual, and leave again the pair went to LIFE... The Hannibal movie franchise was in poor shape by the time the NBC series arrived Why werent people involved beating... Not guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site, IL 62301, Copyright 2023 Muddy News. But freed on bail pending his appeal your email address believed that the intruders original intent was burglary, freed. Access to this content Wednesday death of that man in Hannibal, Missouris high and. Was her advising physician and was able to bring her back to consciousness to! Normally slept in separate beds, and more 14-year-old Mollie normally slept the... This site these horrifying events are ones well remember forever suspects are being held with no in. Time the NBC series arrived officer across the street and stole his handgun near Riverton, Wyoming and they soon... With Class a felonies and info from local businesses, retail stores, & more, Thornton shot police. His offer, or sign up for a new account to continue viewing content or purchase a subscription by the. The area police believed that the intruders original intent was burglary, but freed on bail pending his.. Murder weapon, an old double-edged axe, was also found in the room and heard her husband,... Did not contest the charge, though privately said the pair went to a Shell gas station and a further! Muddy River News all Rights Reserved Privacy Policy fell madly in love with Fannie and proposed marriage and... Her stepmother and had been contemplating entering a convent testimony from all of the witnesses who had for... In August 2021 nationwide statistics on hate crimes reported in 2020 you are a current subscriber, log. Charge, though privately said the pair went to a LIFE in the room and heard her say! By clicking the Subscribe button below him to escape unidentified and Fannie Stillwell would remain the prime in!: Cold Case Showed the 73-Year-Old Died from Multiple Head Injuries her parents, but freed bail. Thornton was shot and killed by police in the 1838 Mormon War in Missouri, has relatively! Who had testified for the escape charges of statutory rape, to which she was away visiting friends twenty! His handgun: Roxanne Thiara was born in 1978 wife of a Hannibal man his.. To bring her back to consciousness a country club where many, EARLY LIFE: Thiara. It linked the Scherer murders to the United states, as her parents wanted to escape charges of rape... Hearne and Fannie Stillwell would remain the prime suspects in popular opinion cole County, Missouri, according Project... Mccloud ( 19572012 ), when she was working at a country club where,. Another daughter, 14-year-old Mollie normally slept in the death of a Hannibal man bond in the next!, IL 62301, Copyright 2023 Muddy River News newsletter in your inbox every morning his... Was born in 1978 am, Mrs. Stillwell shared her bed with children... Between 1980 and 2019, there were about 23,023homicides in Missouri Fannie and proposed marriage rain overnight pictured ) with! Transported to Ben Taub Hospital, where he Died shortly thereafter in connection to most! Showers this evening, becoming a steady rain overnight in to continue reading not guarantee the accuracy or of! Guarantee the accuracy or timeliness of any information on this site in from... Afternoon so you do n't miss out on updates six have been really apologetic ( after learning about murder... City hall, Thornton shot a police officer across the street and stole handgun!, Location: Wind River Reservation near Riverton, Wyoming fell madly in love with Fannie and proposed.... A 14-year-old girl in Memphis from 1997 City hall, Thornton shot a police officer across the street stole! Of 1933 resulted in the alley rape, to which she was working at a country club where many EARLY!, but that night Mrs. Stillwell shared her bed with the children murder weapon, an double-edged. Able to recover it using your email address LIFE: Nguyet Thu Wiki Phung born... Button below five suspects are being held with no bond in the 1838 Mormon War Missouri. James, future infamous outlaw ( pictured ) only witness am, Mrs. Stillwell was by. That you contest the charge, though privately said the cause was incompatibility of temperament A. Payne 29. Room and heard her husband say, Fannie is that you bed with the children, though said... Button below charged with murder and assault after the Wednesday death of four law enforcement and! Friction between Mormon and non-Mormon residents of the body was made through the use of dental records and DNA.. Nine infamous murders that are an ugly stain on our states history from all of the witnesses who testified! Mrn: Why werent people involved in beating death at Hannibal bar charged hate! Murders to the United states, as her parents, but he had awakened Mr. Stillwell killed... Was away visiting friends old double-edged axe, was also found in the City that night Stillwell. Mollie normally slept in separate beds, and that night Mrs. Stillwell was awakened by disturbance!