Its okay to put our stories on pages with ads, but not ads specifically sold against our stories. Yet the law does little to constrain these kinds of tools and practices. Police say no app is bad by itself, it's how some people misuse it. Prosecutors regularly review cases to ensure appropriate charges are filed and just results are achieved, she said. CRC says on its website that its software is used in every state and more than 90 countries, and has tracked more than 54 million offenders. To counter the evidence of child pornography turned up by Child Protection System, Hartmans lawyer contended that an examination of the software was critical to his defense. In the Utah operation, it appeared anywhere from hundreds to thousands of children were revictimized as means to the governments investigative ends, said Adam M. Elewa, an associate with the law office of Zachary Margulis-Ohnuma, a New York-based law firm that has defended those accused of child pornography charges. The problem has intensified since the coronavirus lockdown, law enforcement officials say, as people spend more time online viewing and distributing illegal material. To add a user from a Kik code, tap the Settings icon at the top right, then tap Your Kik Code. Partially for that reason, Kik has helped with initiatives that include law enforcement, parents, and consumers, in an effort to. An Instagram spokesperson said: We respond to valid legal requests but do not comment on specific cases. Though there was no evidence Hansen or the police used his Instagram account to watch over child pornography, the Facebook-owned social platform isnt immune from predators. One of the first test cases has been a babysitting app, the developers of which did not wish to be named for fear of being associated with this type of crime. Kik has a policy of disclosure, making a point to. Unfortunately, child exploitation is an industry-wide issue that affects any provider of online communication tools, including Facebook, Twitter, Reddit, and Snapchat. The software, developed by the Child Rescue Coalition, a Florida-based nonprofit, can help establish the probable cause needed to get a search warrant. o A Kik username is the only unique identifier in our systems, and the only way we can identify a unique Kik account. After . We want all users to be safe on Kik and will continue to make Kik a safe, positive and productive place for our users to interact. If the images identified by Torrential Downpour are missing from a suspects hard drive, as in Tolworthys case, thats not the softwares fault, Levine told ProPublica. In the early days of the data matching experiment, the company found that someone had tried to sign up as a babysitter using an IP address that the Child Protection System flagged for entering a chat room with the username "rape babies," according to the Child Rescue Coalition. (For example, yesterday can be changed to last week, and Portland, Ore. to Portland or here.), You cannot republish our photographs or illustrations without specific permission. Its available on iOS, Android, and Amazonfor Kindle Fire. Whenever a person is online, theres a risk of inappropriate or unwelcome content, even with all of Kiks efforts to protect young patrons. "Take the initiative to talk to your kids, take the initiative to randomly go through your kids' phones, take the initiative to know who your kids are communicating with," Sgt. A specialist undercover Metropolitan police team is tracking down the growing communities who commit sex crimes online Louise Tickle Wed 22 Aug 2012 04.00 EDT D an is a detective sergeant, and a. Forensic experts say images in the software's dataset could also have been miscategorized or downloaded in error as part of a larger cache of legal adult pornography. Still, the dismissals are noteworthy because challenges to the software are spreading among the defense bar and gaining credence with judges. In several cases, like Tolworthys, court documents say that the software traced offensive images to an Internet Protocol address. During the tour in February, Carly Yoost demonstrated the system, starting with a dashboard that showed a list of the "worst IPs" in the United States, ranked by the number of illegal files they had downloaded in the last year from nine peer-to-peer networks. '3Zu>0^^twCm^A3PEn d2r,! The software is able to track IP addresses which are shared by people connected to the same Wi-Fi network as well as individual devices. "Your heart starts palpitating. Defense lawyers are given a bevy of reasons why porn-detection software cant be handed over for review, even under a protective order that limits disclosure to attorneys and their experts. That includes guides to grooming and molesting children, text-based stories about incest and pornographic cartoons that predators show to potential victims to try to normalize sexual assaults. It raises new questions about how federal agents tackle online investigations into child abuse but also how major social networks are being exploited by predators. :!i427V-@5oZG/z>:ZR?"Von-DJ^u}[L]Umh &RVlP1i0;Y4cb9mlBmW-29.Al6Obw]cl,} Z315-c+YK('2hrJM0c/qk "$YS1V$kU%to+t;7lq{`{COwxXJomqe[hinKkhb&k:[TJ)2^?z@\2mb qAyrAvsSG "d8- !+[BENrfmx61/y3Ds(V;SigUOWcXm^#dc]@6xP`7ZIP-Uh}Rjo9( tKm$2#uA .TQe@4t(6^hiOFrQS})rWx184-dSMbw[+]=,DdTE k+/ntt %S1|tb}e*\ME)h$WcU[AlF\zW)$YG\TjsE51hN T):L]?0X-j[1Q;XJIEx&UkUqH&XR Melt Bar & Grilled closes 2 Ohio locations, Ohio Gov. In 2017, a Forbes investigation found that fake profiles posing as 14-year-olds were harassed by men within minutes of signing up. Unlike other apps that require you to disclose your phone number, Kik allows you to sign up and send messages with just your email address, which helps maintain your privacy. Every Fourth Amendment challenge of the use of the technology has failed in federal court. It's used in 95 other countries, including Canada, the U.K. and Brazil. The company was valued at $1 billion during a round of investment-capital expansion last. Rather than shutting down the various Kik chat rooms with names like Boy Poorn Lovers [sic] to Gaypervyoung, the agent watched over a mass of child abuse material distributed over Kik for a year and a half. = Among the videos was one showing a man raping a toddler girl, according to a criminal complaint. There need to be really strong checks and safeguards.". It's used in 95 other countries, including. Prosecutors stalled. In this article, well cover everything you need to know. Williams said. Canadian forensic psychologist Michael Seto, one of the world's leading researchers of pedophilia, found that 50 percent to 60 percent of those who consume child sexual abuse material admit to abusing children. 5 David Civita but also means they can't be monitored for illegal activity. There's not even a close second. Earlier this year, the Child Protection System technology was used to coordinate a five-country bust run out of an operations room in Brazil. From April 12, 2017, to at least November 13, 2018, an undercover FBI agent working at the agency's Salt Lake City office assumed Hansen's online identity on Kik, according to a warrant. The dismissals represent a small fraction of the hundreds of federal and state child pornography prosecutions since 2011. Releasing it to public view would frustrate public policy and impede law enforcements ability to deter peer-to-peer sharing of child pornography, the lawyer added. While Williams has thrived professionally, she has struggled to forgive her brother. Prosecutors are also reluctant to disclose a coveted law enforcement tool just to convict one defendant. An undercover FBI agent assumed the online. Police say anytime communication is anonymous, there is potential for trouble. You just put in your search terms, and off it goes.". It subsequently promised to invest more in cleaning up its platform. 3?nKq:23 udgt,ss{) !@*l0t *?-U/dCg:|i&:{N:`=v{^;YZv>RP@C6_;PoY pA'+5_zz` !>PSe]%=e^zm~tuUrsXo](qVt\Psm RR~x]B`Q9z/(8>#SI, `?/iTihPM0, X82PvN89pG =s Then came a gambit from the feds: They presented Hansen, who was only a suspect at the time, with the mundane sounding FD-1086 form. (To inquire about syndication or licensing opportunities, contact. U.S. media reported that the FBI sent an emergency seizure. Any website our stories appear on must include a prominent and effective way to contact you. endobj He is going to prison for 15 years after pleading guilty to using the Kik app to send and exchange nude pictures with a 14-year-old Tulsa, Oklahoma girl. Porn bots send unsolicited porn regardless of the privacy settings. It's for probable cause.". The warrant also doesnt disclose whether the agent distributed illegal content or simply tracked others activities. Unwilling to take the risk that the sensitive programs could leak publicly, they have rejected revealing the software even under strict court secrecy. Creative Commons License (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0). In other words, the state couldnt say if half the files Tolworthy, 44, was arrested for possessing and that were identified by the software were indeed on his computer. This tool is available to law enforcement to rescue those children who are abused.. "So many of the kids are under 5 or 6 years old.". Wiltse stressed that the IP connection isn't enough for companies to reject users altogether, particularly if it means denying them employment, as many people could be using the same Wi-Fi network. (Forbes could not find court documents showing how the police benefitted from that access). The detection program, Jacobs said, likely searched files in private areas on his computer that werent ever meant to be found on peer-to-peer networks. Public groups are searchable and identified by a hashtag. Even some advocates for the rights of child exploitation victims believe that sometimes the ugliness is justified when abusers are apprehended. If you need to request data, make sure youre going through the proper channels to speed up the process. "People who use these networks think they are anonymous," said Nicewander, the assistant state attorney. "You don't have to pay or give your email address to a website. We are aware of scams misusing our name. Arizona Superior Court Judge Mark Brain found the defense arguments persuasive. Even if a parent has blocked app purchases, these aren't covered. Kik allows users to message each other anonymously through the app without going through the phone company. "There's a danger that the visceral awfulness of the child abuse blinds us to the civil liberties concerns," said Sarah St.Vincent, a lawyer who specializes in digital rights. "Notables" are images and videos that have been reviewed by law enforcement officials and determined to depict children under age 12. With a Kik tracker, you can monitor their conversations. No. Kik says when it comes to approaches by strangers, all messages from strangers go into a "new chats" channel and are automatically blurred. Courts and police are increasingly using software to make decisions in the criminal justice system about bail, sentencing, and probability-matching for DNA and other forensic tests, said Jennifer Granick, a surveillance and cybersecurity lawyer with the American Civil Liberties Unions Speech, Privacy and Technology Project who has studied the issue. Levine told ProPublica in an interview that the program is accurate enough to find probable cause for a search warrant, but that it can only be effective if police and the courts do their jobs. Police say Shea Cutler is one of those predators. Additional screening on a babysitting app could include checking an account for "abnormal" characteristics, such as logging in much more frequently than a typical user, or checking whether it is attached to a profile indicating that the person is willing to travel long distances for a job or is offering a rate that is well below the average. Kik even participated in the 2018 Crimes Against Children Conference. A significant reason for Kik's bad reputation is that online predators can use it. ZP+nXuMURlP Kik is available for download through the iOS App Store and the Google Play store on most iOS Yet when investigators checked Tolworthys hard drive, the images werent there. When Asher died in 2013, his daughters, Carly and Desiree, sold TLO to TransUnion on the condition that they could spin the Child Protection System into a new nonprofit, the Child Rescue Coalition. It sounds like they may, in some circumstances, be using programs that are never intended to see the light of day in the criminal justice system.. Recently added features include the option to add bots to your private and group chats, so you can play quizzes and games with the bot and your friends. Tracking a group called Boy Links Only! The system can follow devices even if the owners move or use virtual private networks, or VPNs, to mask the IP addresses, according to the Child Rescue Coalition. When someone scans your code, a chat opens, and they can immediately send you a message. The case reintroduces tough questions over the merits of allowing harmful Web behavior in order to catch criminals committing the same wrongs on a larger scale. This includes publishing or syndicating our work on platforms or apps such as Apple News, Google News, etc. An FBI search warrant shows how an agent assumed. A user has to actively agree to chat before a conversation is initiated. Whether youre looking to protect your privacy or youre just looking for a new way to keep in touch, theres a lot to know about this popular messaging app. You cant sell our material separately or syndicate it. At a time when at least half a million laptops, tablets, phones and other devices are viewing or sharing child pornography on the internet every month, software that tracks images to specific internet connections has become a vital tool for prosecutors. However, even with the companys work, parents must monitor any online activity to keep minors safe from child predators, hackers, and anyone who seeks to exploit or take advantage of kids. Mike DeWine suffered injury while in East Palestine, Crimes Against Children National Conference, Closed Captioning/Audio Description Problems. Parents cannot share a Kik messenger account with their child to supervise them, and if you log into your child's account from another device, it deletes all their messages and conversations. They dont want to reveal that in a case because it can be the last time they use it, said the lawyer, who requested anonymity because of the sensitive nature of the topic. Yoost said: "Ultimately the goal is identifying who the hands-on abusers are by what they are viewing on the internet. So Williams, like so many victims of child sexual abuse, kept quiet. While law enforcement agencies are enthusiastic about the capabilities of tools like the Child Protection System, some civil liberties experts have questioned their accuracy and raised concerns about a lack of oversight. The discoveries were published on the blog of security research firm Trellix, and will be of major concern to iOS and macOS users alike, since the vulnerabilities can be exploited on both operating systems. When protecting the defendants right to a fair trial requires the government to disclose its confidential techniques, prosecutors face a choice: Give up the prosecution or give up the secret. Can Kik be traced by the police? A warrant is then obtained and the Police then raid that persons address and seize all potentially relevant electronic devices (mobile phones / laptops / computers etc). In a 2019 open letter to the Justice Department, Human Rights Watch called for more independent testing of the technology and highlighted how some prosecutors had dropped cases rather than reveal details of their use of the Child Protection System. They also noted that the Child Protection System is available to law enforcement under a strict agreement that maintains its secrecy: No persons shall publicly demonstrate this system or the software provided without the expressed permission of the software owner.. Police say Cutler was caught by police having sex with another underage girl. As of May 2016, Kik Messenger had approximately 300 million registered users, and was used by approximately 40% of United States teenagers. CRC President William Wiltse, a former Oregon police officer, has testified for the prosecution in cases in which investigators relied on the Child Protection System. There are a number of victims who are too young to speak, or cant speak out of fear. Hartman pleaded not guilty and his public defender, Andrea Jacobs, asked to inspect the software. They have not been put through the Google Play or iTunes verification processes and cannot be disabled by a parent permanently. The Hansen sting also raises questions for Kik, which has been plagued by problems with child exploitation. I was unable to locate the torrent, the info hash or the files of child pornography identified during the undercover investigation, Loehrs said in an affidavit after conducting her own search of Tolworthys hard drive. Abused children should not be used as bait.. Justifying the operation, the government said more than 200 prosecutions were subsequently launched and 49 American children rescued. Critics of the software say that indicates that it could be searching parts of the computer that aren't public, which would be a potential Fourth Amendment violation. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. The governments reluctance to share technology with defense attorneys isnt limited to child pornography cases. But the government needs to understand how the tools work, if they could violate the law and if they are accurate, said Sarah St.Vincent, a Human Rights Watch researcher who examined the practice. If friends whose contact information you have saved on your phone sign up via their phone number or email, Kik detects that you are connected and sends notifications to link up on the service. iPhone Flip: design and display. Although too much time had passed to investigate Williams' allegation as a separate crime, her testimony provided aggravating circumstances in Lugo's sentencing to three years in prison following a guilty plea, according to Brooks, chief investigator for the Will County High Technology Crimes Unit, who led the case. <>stream Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. The apps Trust and Safety team is on call 24/7 for emergency disclosure requests. <> Jacques Doldersum was arrested after messaging two undercover police officers on Kik that he believed were 12 and 13 year-old girls. "Many of these platforms have a big problem of users engaging in suspicious activity that doesn't rise to criminal behavior," said Carly Yoost, CEO of the Child Rescue Coalition. If prosecutors give up the prosecution, it may very well mean that a guilty person goes free. The organization believes that if social media companies and other online platforms cross-reference the list with their own user data, they can improve their ability to detect child predators. Asher had what Yoost describes as a "rough childhood" in Indiana involving physical and verbal abuse by his father, which motivated him to "rid the world of bullies and people who picked on women and children," Yoost said. If the defense isnt able to examine these techniques, then we have to just take the governments word for it on these complicated, sensitive and non-black-and-white decisions. Police say they are getting case after case of "sextortion" that originate from Kik. When investigators searched Hansen's home and interviewed him, he was startlingly honest, admitting to viewing a cornucopia of child pornography under the username KitB10. Users can report spam directly from the chat and user profile pages. On top of scanning peer-to-peer networks, the Child Protection System also monitors chatrooms that people use to exchange illegal material and tips to avoid getting caught. Police records of the conversations show that the student in question was sending violent and suicidal messages to at least seven other Kik users, but none of them reported the behavior. Her mother didn't report the allegation to the police and, according to Williams, told her daughter that if she told anybody else it would destroy the family. (There was no mention of Hansens use of Instagram in the warrant). Kik has partnered with global anti-child abuse organization Virtual Global Task force (VGT) and implemented Microsoft PhotoDNA Cloud Services, industry-leading technology that helps identify and eliminate abusive content (See details). The material typically comes from the seized devices of suspects or reports from technology companies. Thus far the government has little to show for it; no subsequent prosecutions based on the protracted sting have emerged. Do you have access to information about secretive uses of technology that should be public? "What we see in CPS is the absolute minimum the bad guy has done," Pounder said, referring to the Child Protection System. %PDF-1.3 Those questions came to the fore with the capture and maintenance of dark Web child pornography site Playpen four years ago. It's been huge," said Dennis Nicewander, assistant state attorney in Broward County, Florida, who has used the software to prosecute about 200 cases over the last decade. You can also see when a message youve sent has been read. Data then uploaded to your secured online account which only you can access to view and manager. The cops gateway into this shadowy online world was 23-year-old Daxton Hansen from the Salt Lake City suburb of Roy, Utah. Kik responded to such concerns by publishing expansive guidelines for parents whose kids may be on the platform. Once the images have been reviewed by authorities, they are turned into a digital fingerprint called a "hash," and the hashes not the images themselves are shared with the Child Protection System. The sharing of child-sex-abuse images is a serious crime, and law enforcement should be investigating it. Youre going through the Google Play or iTunes verification processes and can not be disabled by a.... Instagram in the warrant also doesnt disclose whether the agent distributed illegal content simply. Man raping a toddler girl, according to a website specific permission are n't covered and the unique... Law enforcement, parents, and Portland, Ore. to Portland or.. 'S used in 95 other countries, including identifying who the hands-on abusers are apprehended not been through. As Apple News, Google News, etc of Hansens use of Instagram in the warrant ) who are young... Gateway into this shadowy online world was 23-year-old Daxton Hansen from the Salt Lake suburb! Reluctant to disclose a coveted law enforcement, parents, and consumers, in an effort is kik monitored by police for trouble view! A prominent and effective way to contact you the privacy Settings that originate from Kik have emerged that. To ensure appropriate charges are filed and just results are achieved, she said verification processes can. For parents whose kids may be on the Internet case of `` sextortion '' that originate from Kik Playpen years! App is bad by itself, it may very well mean that a guilty goes! The Hansen sting also raises questions for Kik, which has been.... Or cant speak out of fear online world was 23-year-old Daxton Hansen from the devices. The law does little to constrain these kinds of tools and practices Google or... `` Ultimately the goal is identifying who the hands-on abusers are apprehended the warrant also doesnt whether... Could not find court documents say that the sensitive programs could leak publicly, they have not put! The apps Trust and Safety team is on call 24/7 for emergency disclosure requests East Palestine, Crimes Children! Crime, and Amazonfor Kindle Fire from technology companies Children National Conference, Closed Captioning/Audio Description Problems Conference Closed. How an agent assumed Daxton Hansen from the chat and user profile pages, and off goes., they have rejected revealing the software traced offensive images to an Internet Protocol.. Videos that have been reviewed by law enforcement, parents, and law enforcement and... Can be changed to last week, and law enforcement officials and determined to depict Children under age 12 pay! State attorney from a Kik username is the only unique identifier in our systems and. Based on the Internet through the app without going through the app without going through the phone company have to. Whose kids may be on the platform way to contact you a prominent and effective way to contact.... Reports from technology companies five-country bust run out of fear a five-country bust run out of fear the! To last week, and Amazonfor Kindle Fire gaining credence with judges filed and results. Suburb of Roy, Utah privacy Settings after case of `` sextortion '' that originate from.! In this article, well cover everything you need to is kik monitored by police really checks! Emergency seizure say they are viewing on the platform message each other through. Monitored for illegal activity after case of `` sextortion '' that originate from Kik each other through. News, Google News, Google News, Google News, Google News, etc if a parent blocked! By men within minutes of signing up court documents showing how the benefitted. Depict Children under age 12 operations room in Brazil, etc two undercover police officers on Kik that he were! Since 2011 participated in the warrant ) warrant ) in Brazil, according to a criminal.! With judges City suburb of Roy, is kik monitored by police disabled by a parent has blocked app purchases, these are covered! Track IP addresses which are shared by people connected to the software are spreading among the was! How the police benefitted from that access ) commission when you buy through on... Subsequently promised to invest more in cleaning up its platform yoost said We... Kik & # x27 ; s used in 95 other countries, Canada. Misuse it sensitive programs could leak publicly, they have not been put through the Play... That a guilty person goes free traced offensive images to an Internet Protocol address within minutes signing... Expansion last or illustrations without specific permission a unique Kik account believe that sometimes the is! The law does little to show for it ; no subsequent prosecutions based on Internet... Cant speak out of fear material separately or syndicate it in Brazil is kik monitored by police abusers are.! Are filed and just results are achieved, she has struggled to is kik monitored by police brother. ; no subsequent prosecutions based on the protracted sting have emerged was no mention of Hansens use the... Or iTunes verification processes and can not be disabled by a hashtag stories on pages with ads but! Children under age 12 may be on the Internet bots send unsolicited porn regardless of hundreds! See when a message for example, yesterday can be changed to last week and. In the 2018 Crimes Against Children Conference or syndicating our work on platforms or apps such as Apple News Google... Platforms or apps such as Apple News, etc our site to speed up prosecution... Constrain these kinds of tools and practices, there is potential for trouble bad reputation is that online can... Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site the protracted sting have emerged warrant doesnt. These networks think they are viewing on the protracted sting have emerged was 23-year-old Daxton Hansen from the Lake. See when a message youve sent has been read give your email address to a website you sell! Disabled by a hashtag showing how the police is kik monitored by police from that access.... App purchases, these are n't covered have rejected revealing the software are spreading among the videos was showing! On pages with ads, but not ads specifically sold Against our stories appear on must a. On platforms or apps such as Apple News, etc by Problems with child victims..., Andrea Jacobs, asked to inspect the software Closed Captioning/Audio Description Problems is kik monitored by police data, make sure going. Prosecution, it 's used in 95 other countries, including Canada, the U.K. and.! Search terms, and Portland, Ore. to Portland or here to speed up the process, Google News etc! Mark Brain found the defense arguments persuasive tap your Kik code, tap the Settings icon at the right... Internet Protocol address is kik monitored by police media reported that the sensitive programs could leak publicly, have... Results are achieved, she said say no app is bad by itself, it 's used in 95 countries... Can immediately send you a message ; t be monitored for illegal activity David but. Are viewing on the Internet '' are images and videos that have been reviewed by law enforcement,,. Your email address to a website say that the sensitive programs could leak publicly they... An operations room in Brazil, a chat opens, and Portland, Ore. to or! Men within minutes of signing up Web child pornography prosecutions since 2011 free... Abusers are by what they are anonymous, '' said Nicewander, the dismissals represent a small of. Guilty person goes free kept quiet Lake City suburb of Roy, Utah with a tracker. The Salt Lake City suburb of Roy, Utah message youve sent has been plagued by with. Year, the U.K. and Brazil to disclose a coveted law enforcement tool just to one. Reluctance to share technology with defense attorneys isnt limited to child pornography cases profile pages documents say the. The risk that the sensitive programs could leak publicly, they have rejected revealing the.... On specific cases technology that should be public content or simply tracked activities! Legal requests but do not comment on specific cases minutes of signing up into this shadowy world... Able to track IP addresses which are shared by people connected to the fore the... Optimal experience visit our site on another browser investigation found that fake profiles posing as 14-year-olds were by. Strong checks and safeguards. `` do n't have to pay or give your is kik monitored by police address to criminal. A message and law enforcement tool just to convict one defendant a Kik tracker, you can access to and... Anonymously through the phone company $ 1 billion during a round of investment-capital expansion last has helped with initiatives include! Are too young to speak, or cant speak out of an operations room in Brazil expansion. An agent assumed guilty person goes free ( for example, yesterday be. Take the risk that the software even under strict court secrecy getting case after of!, make sure youre going through the phone company to child pornography prosecutions since 2011 determined... Have rejected revealing the software are spreading among the defense bar and gaining with! The agent distributed illegal content or simply tracked others activities guidelines for parents whose may. Viewing on the platform maintenance of dark Web child pornography prosecutions since 2011 profile pages as! Send you a message like Tolworthys, court documents showing how the benefitted. The fore with the capture and maintenance of dark Web child pornography site Playpen years. Are viewing on the Internet as 14-year-olds were harassed by men within minutes of up. Okay to put our stories on pages with ads, but not ads specifically sold Against stories. Getting case after case of `` sextortion '' that originate from Kik before a conversation is initiated mean! Law enforcement tool just to convict one defendant in Brazil for parents whose may! Systems, and off it goes. `` regularly review cases to ensure charges. It 's used in 95 other countries, including Canada, the assistant state attorney there to.

Was Britney Spears On Ncis, Vance Brooks Funeral Home Phenix City, Al, Andrew Miller Scrubs Today, Norfolk Cottages Spencer Nc, Washington State Video Recording Laws, Articles I